Norwood Man Acquitted After Judge Questions Jury In Anarchy Case
In Dedham District Court, a tense legal drama unfolded when Segris Zakoff of Norwood was brought to trial on charges of advocating anarchy. The case drew unusual attention after Judge Webster Thayer directly questioned the jurymen about their reasoning, an uncommon step that underscored the era’s anxieties surrounding political radicalism.
Police officers Chief Harry Swift, Patrolman William Barrett, and Patrolman Peter Curran testified that Zakoff had expressed sympathy for Bolshevism and dissatisfaction with the government. But the jury, led by its foreman, concluded that while Zakoff may have voiced political opinions, he had not advocated violent overthrow, which the statute required for conviction.
Defense attorney Percy A. Katzmann argued that Zakoff’s statements were protected expressions of belief, while prosecutor William Kane pressed the charge. After deliberation, the jury returned a verdict of not guilty, emphasizing that no evidence showed Zakoff had urged force or violence.
The exchange between the judge and the jury highlighted a community grappling with national fears of radicalism while still upholding the legal threshold for criminal advocacy. For Norwood, the case became a local example of the tension between public safety concerns and civil liberties during the post‑World War I Red Scare.
Source: Boston Globe, April 24, 1920
More Norwood Crime Stories
-
Makarewicz Guilty In Slaying of Geraldine Annese-This Day in Norwood History-March 18, 1955
Sentenced to Life on Jury’s Request Peter William Makarewicz, 16, was convicted at 6:02 last night of first-degree murder for the Nov. 4 strangling of vivacious Geraldine Annese, 15, who lived only a stone’s throw from his Norwood home. The gangling, handsome defendant was whisked from Dedham to Charlestown State Prison early last night to…
-
Life Sentence Begins-This Day in Norwood History-March 18, 1955
Slim, boyishly handsome Peter Makarewicz, 16, of Norwood, begins a life sentence in state prison today for the sex strangling of his school chum and neighbor, Geraldine Annese, 15. Joseph Annese, 63, father of the slain girl, who lived only a block from the Makarewicz home, commented grimly: “The verdict was okay. But I would feel better if he got…
-
Defense Counsel In Plea For Not Guilty Verdict As Murder Trial Ends-This Day in Norwood History-March 17, 1955
An hour and three quarters’ fervent plea for the return of a not guilty verdict for his youthful client, Peter Makarewicz, echoed through the courtroom at Dedham this morning as the Chief Defense Counsel, Louis Goldstein, summarized his case before the jury sitting in the Annese Murder Case. “Don’t let anyone shift the responsibility of…
-
Peter Makarewicz Makes Own Plea To Jury-This Day in Norwood History-March 17, 1955
Young Peter Makarewicz told the jury this afternoon that he did not murder Geraldine Annese and asked that he be acquitted. The 16-year-old defendant making his plea in a calm voice from the prisoner’s cage said: “I have been accused of a crime I did not commit and I only hope that the verdict you…
-
“I Didn’t Kill Her,” Says Peter-This Day in Norwood History-March 15, 1955
Norwood Youth Denies Confession DEDHAM, March 15—Peter Makarewicz took the stand today in his own defense on the eighth day of his first-degree murder trial. The slim, pale 16-year-old boy, under questioning by his attorney, Louis Goldstein, gave the court an hour-by-hour account of his activities on Nov. 4, the day on which the Commonwealth…
-
Peter Makarewicz Denies Confession-“I Didn’t Kill Her,” He Says-This Day in Norwood History-March 15, 1955
DEDHAM, March 15—Peter Makarewicz took the stand today in his own defense on the eighth day of his first-degree murder trial. The slim, pale 16-year-old hoy, under questioning by his attorney, Louis Goldstein, gave the court an hour-by-hour account of his activities on Nov. 4, the day on which the Commonwealth of Massachusetts says he…
-
Parents, Brother Ready to Take Stand for Peter Makarewicz-This Day in Norwood History-March 14, 1955
Fingerprint Experts, Doctors to Testify in Norwood Slaying DEDHAM. March 13-The parents and 14-year-old brother of Peter W. Makarewfcz, 18, of Norwood, will testify on his behalf. attorney Louis Goldstein disclosed tonight. The parents, Mr. and Mrs. Peter A. Makarewics, and brother, Richard, probably will be the first defense witnesses called, Goldstein said. One or…
-
Dungaree Clue Found In Washer, Says Detective-This Day In Norwood History-March 11, 1955
By PAUL V. CRAIGUE Stained dungarees which the prosecution claims caused Peter Makarewicz to “break’ and make his alleged confession of murdering 15-year-old Geraldine Annese were found in his mother’s washing machine, it was testified today. The testimony was given by State Police Sgt. Walter Bogdanchik who has recited in detail the young defendant’s alleged…
-
Jury Hears ‘Confession’ of Strangling Girl, 15-This Day in Norwood History-March 11, 1955
Trooper Says Peter Told Details After Breaking Under 4th Quiz DEDHAM. March 10-A packed but hushed courtroom and an attentive 14-man Jury listened with rapt attention this afternoon as a State Police sergeant bared for the first time the sordid details of the alleged murder confession of Peter Makarewicz. Defense attorney Louis Goldstein legally dueled…
-
Peter Makarewicz Refused to Take Lie Test, Says Officer-This Day in Norwood History-March 10, 1955
Boy Couldn’t Explain Blood Traces, Jury Told DEDHAM. March 10 — Peter Makarewicz refused to submit to a lie detector test when he was questioned about the murder of 15-year-old Geraldine Annese, it was testified today at the trial of the boy. The testimony was offered by State Police Sgt Walter Bogdanchik, who recounted the…
Text and images may have been edited, colorized, or digitally restored with the assistance of AI tools such as Microsoft Copilot or Google Gemini. All content is reviewed for accuracy and historical integrity before publication by the Norwood Historical Society
Discover more from Norwood Historical Society
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.