Customers Debate “Christmas Creep” as Retailers Launch Holiday Displays in October While Busy Working Families Shop Ahead

NORWOOD – With Thanksgiving Day still nearly a week away, Norwood resident Betty Ann Testa was already browsing the aisles of Paperama, the popular discount party-supply store on Route 1 (Boston-Providence Highway), on Sunday, November 19, 1989, hunting for finishing touches on her holiday checklist—including red and green wrapping paper, tinsel, and Santa gift boxes. Reported by Patriot Ledger staff writer Lyndsey Layton on Monday, November 20, 1989, Testa and dozens of fellow shoppers were plowing through Christmas preparations weeks—and even months—ahead of the day after Thanksgiving, the traditional kickoff of the holiday retail season.

“I’ve been at it since the summer,” said Testa, who was picking out wrapping paper alongside her sister, Claire Hughes of Roslindale. “Each year the season starts earlier and earlier. Santa Claus was at the South Shore Plaza today. Can you believe it? Thanksgiving is completely forgotten. All people talk about is Christmas.”

Inside Paperama on the Sunday before Thanksgiving, autumn holiday merchandise had already been pushed to the margins. A few dozen turkey basters sat tucked into a corner beside Pilgrim figurines beneath a single dangling paper-cutout turkey—while just around the corner in aisle one, Christmas reigned in full force. Shiny red, green, and white garlands hung from the ceiling alongside Santa Claus and reindeer pinatas, empty wooden mangers sat scattered across a sale table next to a bin of jumbled, upside-down nativity figures, fake snow frosted the front storefront window, and mechanical carolers waved cheerfully at customers waiting in the checkout line.

According to a store manager, Paperama had launched its Christmas merchandise displays in mid-October—yet even that proved too late for Jennifer Van Strum and Patricia Spiegel of Randolph. The two friends had driven to Norwood early in October hoping to stock up on holiday decorations, only to find the shelves bare. “But the store didn’t even have them yet,” Van Strum recalled on Sunday as she and Spiegel wheeled out a shopping cart loaded with $150 worth of bows, stockings, electric candles, ornaments, banners, and supplies for a December holiday party. Spiegel argued that busy modern schedules, rather than retail hype alone, drove families to shop early: “People are working more and there just isn’t enough time to get all the shopping done in December. All of our friends have two jobs and we’re all exhausted. You don’t want to have to run around like crazy for the last two weeks. Starting earlier makes a lot more sense.”

Vintage newspaper advertisement for Paperama featuring 50% off board games, stocking stuffers, candy, gifts, holiday party supplies, plastic tableware, and New Year’s 1990 promotions.

Not every customer picking through plastic poinsettias and Santa tie tacks welcomed the accelerated calendar, however. “It’s really disappointing that the season starts so early,” said Marianne, a Norwood resident who declined to give her last name after entering the store for a Thanksgiving tablecloth only to find herself bargain-hunting in the Christmas aisle. “The pace has really quickened. And it’s unfortunate. It’s all designed so the stores can make more money.” Holding a stack of snowman-decorated cookie boxes, she contrasted the quiet gratitude of Thanksgiving with December retail frenzy: “Thanksgiving is such a special holiday, there’s so much giving from the heart. There is no commercialism. Yes, you buy a turkey. But that’s about it. You take the time be thankful for your families or good health. There’s just so much truism in it. I wish Christmas could be like that.”

1989 Holiday Party Supply Purchase Adjusted to 2026 Dollars & Route 1 Retail Context

Inflation-adjusted using U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI data ($1.00 in Nov. 1989 ≈ $2.62 in 2026)

1989 Norwood Route 1 Holiday Shopping Purchase 1989 Purchase 2026 Equivalent
Shopping Cart of Christmas Party Decorations & Supplies at Paperama $150.00 ~$393.00
Retail Corridor Today (2026): Located along Norwood’s Route 1 (Boston-Providence Highway) shopping corridor, regional discount party chain Paperama was later acquired by Party City in the late 1990s—operating along the same Route 1 retail strip that continues to draw South Shore holiday shoppers today.

Archival Note: This article has been dynamically reconstructed from the original public record print archives of the Patriot Ledger

  • Olde Colonial Café Closes Its Doors After 56 Years-December 26, 2025

    Olde Colonial Café Closes Its Doors After 56 Years-December 26, 2025

    After 56 years of serving the Norwood community, iconic family restaurant Olde Colonial Café closes its doors as owner Paul Angelo retires.

  • From Gilded Age Roots to Modern Restoration: The Story of Oakview Mansion

    From Gilded Age Roots to Modern Restoration: The Story of Oakview Mansion

    Set high on a rise along Walpole Street, Oakview Mansion stands as a monument to Norwood’s industrial prosperity and architectural elegance. Originally built in 1868 for tanning heir Francis Olney Winslow, this Second Empire landmark later served as the “Executive Mansion” for Massachusetts Governor Frank Allen. From hosting world-renowned figures like Sergei Rachmaninoff and Calvin…

  • Brenner’s Children’s Shop Closes After 50 Years-February 1, 2023

    Brenner’s Children’s Shop Closes After 50 Years-February 1, 2023

    After fifty years of serving the local community, Brenner’s Children’s Shop, located at 694 Washington St has officially closed its doors for good. Owners Aron and Martha Greenfieldot provided school uniforms, scout attire, and formal children’s clothing across three generations and also made a lasting impact on the community. Aron, a Polish Jew, had a…

  • 1000 Year Storm Hits Norwood, Massive Flooding, Hospital Evacuated-June 28, 2020

    1000 Year Storm Hits Norwood, Massive Flooding, Hospital Evacuated-June 28, 2020

    A historic “back building” thunderstorm on June 28, 2020, dropped over four inches of rain on Norwood in ninety minutes, causing catastrophic flooding that completely knocked out power at Norwood Hospital and forced an emergency evacuation.

  • Norwood Sport Center

    Norwood Sport Center

    Explore the history of the Norwood Sport Center on Cottage Street in Norwood, MA, opened in 1940, featured in Hollywood films, and operating until its 2024 closure. Frank Sherwood opened the Norwood Sport Center on October 3, 1940. Modeled after the “Belgian Building” featured in the 1939 World’s Fair, it cost $50,000 to build, a…

  • Building 19: The Store That Became Folklore

    Building 19: The Store That Became Folklore

    Building 19 in Norwood wasn’t just a discount store—it became a local legend, spawning ghost stories, urban myths, and tales of strange sightings that still circulate today. From mysterious noises in the warehouse to rumors of secret tunnels beneath Route 1, the site has inspired decades of speculation and storytelling. Building 19 was a chain…

  • Flood Revives Push For New Police Station-August 9, 1998

    Flood Revives Push For New Police Station-August 9, 1998

    Despite previous failures, new vote likely in Norwood NORWOOD – August 9- Nearly two months have passed since five feet of water inundated the basement of the police station during a torrential June rainstorm. The soaked furniture, files, and paneling have been removed, crucial records are being restored by a special freeze-drying process, the detective…

  • Babel’s- Pinch Me… This Can’t Be a Paint Store! (1996)

    Babel’s- Pinch Me… This Can’t Be a Paint Store! (1996)

    The transformation of Babel’s from a small wallpaper store in the 1950’s to the full-service, full-scale decorating center it is today accelerated dramatically over the past four years. In the midst of New England’s recession, Victor Babel, the second-generation owner, had a vision of what his retail store should look like, and expanded the building,…

  • End of the Line For Kline’s Department Store-November 14, 1994

    End of the Line For Kline’s Department Store-November 14, 1994

    NORWOOD – The racks in Kline’s basement children’s clothing section were bare. Beneath the knotty pine wall panels in the men’s department, bargain hunters strolled along the thin carpets and linoleum floors one morning last week and picked over piles of jeans. Manager Marilyn Wolfson, who first started working in the 81-year-old Norwood Center landmark…

  • Butters Family Sells Pharmacy-July 20, 1990

    Butters Family Sells Pharmacy-July 20, 1990

    A significant chapter in the history of South Norwood business and family legacy came to an end on July 20, 1990. The Butters family pharmacy, a staple in the community for over four decades, ceased operations after Helen Butters, the selectman’s mother and president of the family business, decided to sell the pharmaceutical stock and…


Discover more from Norwood Historical Society

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.