Official Recommends Exploring Mechanical Voting Machines Over Punch-Card Tabulators to Replace Norwood’s Paper Ballots

NORWOOD – Following an official fact-finding trip to observe Newton’s newly installed electronic voting system during its November 7, 1967 municipal election, Norwood Town Clerk Bartley W. Connolly reported on Thursday, November 16, 1967, that he was unimpressed by computerized punch-card balloting—though he emphasized that Norwood urgently needed to replace its increasingly obsolete hand-counted paper ballots. Accompanied on the Newton inspection by Town Manager Walter A. Blasenek and two additional members of the selectmen’s committee studying modern voting techniques, Connolly concluded that mechanical voting machines represented a far more reliable investment if the town could resolve cost and storage hurdles.

According to Connolly, equipping Norwood to handle its 14,000 registered voters would require purchasing approximately 40 mechanical voting machines at an estimated cost of $1,900 apiece—a total capital outlay of roughly $76,000. Beyond the purchase price, Connolly pointed out a logistical challenge: because the Norwood Armory lacked sufficient floor space to house 40 bulky machines between elections, the municipality would need to rent dedicated storage facilities.

Concerns Over Accuracy and Overnight Delays in Newton’s Punch-Card Trial

While acknowledging that the compact punch-card apparatus—which he described as “more like a small desk blotter made of plastic” where voters turned cellophane ballot pages and punched holes with a stylus for computer tabulation—presented zero storage problems and enjoyed smooth voter acceptance in Newton, Connolly warned that the underlying technology remained unproven. Prior to Newton’s rollout, the system had only been tested once locally on a very small scale in Braintree.

Connolly cited serious accuracy and efficiency problems witnessed firsthand during Newton’s ballot count. “I didn’t think it was impressive. It didn’t even seem to be wholly accurate,” Connolly stated. “Not only did it take them until three in the morning to count the votes, but they also got different answers on several tabulations.” Refusing to adopt an untested system prematurely, he cautioned, “I don’t want to jump from the frying pan into the fire.”

At the same time, Connolly stressed that sticking indefinitely with hand-counted paper ballots posed its own threat to election integrity as Norwood’s population expanded. “You can’t be accurate either if you have to stay up all night counting paper ballots,” he observed. “Norwood is growing all the time. It would be wise to find a new method of counting the votes before we lose accuracy because we have to stay up all night.”

1967 Voting Machine Costs Adjusted to 2026 Dollars & Modern Elections

Inflation-adjusted using U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI data ($1.00 in Nov. 1967 ≈ $9.66 in 2026)

1967 Equipment Estimate 1967 Cost 2026 Equivalent
Single Mechanical Voting Machine (Unit Price) $1,900 ~$18,354
Full Fleet of 40 Machines (For 14,000 Voters) $76,000 ~$734,160
Elections Today (2026): Rather than bulky lever voting machines or 1960s punch-card styluses, Norwood elections today—serving more than 21,000 registered voters across nine precincts—use paper ballots marked by hand and scanned instantaneously by state-certified digital optical-scan tabulators, preserving a verifiable paper trail while delivering results minutes after polls close.

Archival Note: This article has been dynamically reconstructed from the original public record print archives of the Patriot Ledger


Discover more from Norwood Historical Society

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.