Judge Hallisey Schedules Friday Hearing on Injunction Bid After Dempsey, Rich, and Lydon Sign Cinema at Norwood Permit “Under Protest”

NORWOOD – A Norfolk Superior Court judge declined on Wednesday morning, November 21, 1973, to issue an immediate restraining order blocking the Cinema at Norwood from screening the X-rated Marlon Brando drama “Last Tango in Paris” that evening, instead scheduling a formal court hearing for Friday, November 23, to determine whether an injunction should be granted. Reported in The Patriot Ledger on Wednesday, November 21, 1973 (combining breaking morning court coverage with full reporting of the Tuesday night Norwood Board of Selectmen session), Judge Hallisey’s ruling followed a tense municipal standoff in which selectmen reluctantly signed a Sunday exhibition license for the film’s scheduled November 25 showing while simultaneously directing Town Counsel Justin C. Barton to ask Dedham Superior Court to halt the screenings.

During Tuesday evening’s meeting, three selectmen—Walter J. Dempsey, Charles L. Rich, and John F. Lydon—signed the Sunday license “under protest” only after Town Counsel Barton warned that refusing the permit could expose the Town of Norwood to financial liability for damages. Board Chairman William F. Butters and Selectman Joseph W. Wall refused to sign the license altogether.

Barton offered selectmen sobering legal guidance, explaining that recent U.S. Supreme Court obscenity rulings had created “greater confusion than previously” regarding X-rated films. Under the new legal standard, Barton noted, prosecutors had to prove that a motion picture’s dominant theme appealed to the prurient interest of the average person, was patently offensive to statewide community standards, and lacked any socially redeeming value. He added that “Last Tango in Paris” had not yet been tested under Massachusetts obscenity statutes—noting that officials in Danvers had tried unsuccessfully to block it, and that an attorney involved in X-rated film disputes in Norwell had told him he “seriously doubted the movie would be considered obscene.”

Selectman Dempsey, who had previously withheld comment on the license application, told the meeting he had “taken a few hours off” earlier Tuesday to view the film firsthand, offering a terse three-word verdict: “Dirty, vulgar and degrading.” Nevertheless, to shield the town from potential lawsuits while pursuing judicial intervention, Barton advised signing the Sunday permit and immediately seeking a court injunction. As members affixed their signatures to pave the way for the Superior Court petition, Chairman Butters remarked, “It’s the only tool we’ve got left.”

Archival Note: This article has been dynamically reconstructed from the original public record print archives of the Patriot Ledger

More…

  • Attorney Responds to Charges Regarding Norwest Woods Development-August 31, 1971

    Attorney John J. Mulvehill appeared before the Planning Board to vigorously contest statements made by planner Thomas F. Cavanaugh regarding the ongoing cleanup and unfinished conditions at the Norwest Woods Apartments complex off Nahatan Street. The sharp exchange marked the latest development in local oversight of the private residential project owned by Sol Siegel. Dispute…

  • Gridlock Over $6-Million Junior High Rebuilding Plan and Norwood Arena Noise-This Day in Norwood History-June 27, 1971

    A dual crisis hits Norwood in 1971 as a $6-million junior high deficit triggers political warfare and state experts condemn racetrack noise.

    Teacher writing school budget details on chalkboard with students listening and thinking about funding issues
  • Master Allows Testimony In Norwood Arena Hearing-June 25, 1971

    Abutters from Norton Drive and Deerfield Road testify that Saturday night stock car racing volumes make normal domestic conversation impossible.

    Attorney arguing in Massachusetts courtroom with judge and jury
  • Attorney Files Petition For New Trial in Local Murder-October 6, 1955

    Attorney Files Petition For New Trial in Local Murder-This Day In Norwood History-October 6, 1955

  • Defense Counsel In Plea For Not Guilty Verdict As Murder Trial Ends-March 17, 1955

    An hour and three quarters’ fervent plea for the return of a not guilty verdict for his youthful client, Peter Makarewicz, echoed through the courtroom at Dedham this morning as the Chief Defense Counsel, Louis Goldstein, summarized his case before the jury sitting in the Annese Murder Case. “Don’t let anyone shift the responsibility of…

  • Defense Bans Women Jurors in Murder Trial-March 7, 1955

    Eleven male jurors were selected by 2:45 this afternoon to hear the case in Norfolk Superior Court of 15-year-old Peter Makarewicz of Norwood, charged with the Nov. 5 murder of vivacious Geraldine Annese, 15, also of Norwood. It is expected that the entire panel of 12 jurors and two alternates will be completed before today’s…

  • Few Details Emerge In Case Against Peter Makarewicz On Eve Of Trial For Murder of Geraldine Annese-March 6, 1955

    DEDHAM. March 6- Tall, slim, delicately handsome Peter Makarewicz, 15, of Norwood, goes on trial in Norfolk Superior Court Monday for the murder of pretty, 15-year-old Geraldine Annese, whose nude body was found in a garage next to her Norwood noma last Nov. 5. Makarewicz, long-time friend and neighbor of the slain, dark-haired high school…

  • Peter Makarewicz Goes on Trial Next Monday in Murder of Geraldine Annese-March 3, 1955

    May Require Two Days To Select Jury By E. V. McLEAN Peler Makarewicz, 15-year-old South Norwood youth who is charged with the strangle slaying of his neighbor and school chum, Geraldine Annese on the night of last November 4, will go on trial for his life in the Norfolk Superior Criminal Court at Dedham on…

  • Court Orders Grow Family To Vacate VFW-This Day In Norwood History-August 27, 1948

    All order to vacate within two weeks or face a jail sentence for contempt of court was handed down in Dedham District Court Saturday by Judge Gilbert U Cox to Donald Grow, 27 wounded Manne veteran who has made his home with his wife and three mung children in the VFW Headquarters on Railroad avenue…

  • New General Manager Ed Monahan Knows Problems of Home Owner, Businessman, Industrialist-This Day in Norwood History-March 28, 1947

    “Ed” Monahan Wades Into New Job With Both Feet On Ground By WIN EVERETT Norwood—meet your sixth full-time General Manager, Edward C. Monahan, who took his official seat in the Memorial Municipal Building Monday morning at 10 o’clock. Last Thursday this reporter interviewed Mr. Monahan in his big, comfortable, oak-shaded home which he owns at…


Discover more from Norwood Historical Society

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.