Judge Hallisey Schedules Friday Hearing on Injunction Bid After Dempsey, Rich, and Lydon Sign Cinema at Norwood Permit “Under Protest”

NORWOOD – A Norfolk Superior Court judge declined on Wednesday morning, November 21, 1973, to issue an immediate restraining order blocking the Cinema at Norwood from screening the X-rated Marlon Brando drama “Last Tango in Paris” that evening, instead scheduling a formal court hearing for Friday, November 23, to determine whether an injunction should be granted. Reported in The Patriot Ledger on Wednesday, November 21, 1973 (combining breaking morning court coverage with full reporting of the Tuesday night Norwood Board of Selectmen session), Judge Hallisey’s ruling followed a tense municipal standoff in which selectmen reluctantly signed a Sunday exhibition license for the film’s scheduled November 25 showing while simultaneously directing Town Counsel Justin C. Barton to ask Dedham Superior Court to halt the screenings.

During Tuesday evening’s meeting, three selectmen—Walter J. Dempsey, Charles L. Rich, and John F. Lydon—signed the Sunday license “under protest” only after Town Counsel Barton warned that refusing the permit could expose the Town of Norwood to financial liability for damages. Board Chairman William F. Butters and Selectman Joseph W. Wall refused to sign the license altogether.

Barton offered selectmen sobering legal guidance, explaining that recent U.S. Supreme Court obscenity rulings had created “greater confusion than previously” regarding X-rated films. Under the new legal standard, Barton noted, prosecutors had to prove that a motion picture’s dominant theme appealed to the prurient interest of the average person, was patently offensive to statewide community standards, and lacked any socially redeeming value. He added that “Last Tango in Paris” had not yet been tested under Massachusetts obscenity statutes—noting that officials in Danvers had tried unsuccessfully to block it, and that an attorney involved in X-rated film disputes in Norwell had told him he “seriously doubted the movie would be considered obscene.”

Selectman Dempsey, who had previously withheld comment on the license application, told the meeting he had “taken a few hours off” earlier Tuesday to view the film firsthand, offering a terse three-word verdict: “Dirty, vulgar and degrading.” Nevertheless, to shield the town from potential lawsuits while pursuing judicial intervention, Barton advised signing the Sunday permit and immediately seeking a court injunction. As members affixed their signatures to pave the way for the Superior Court petition, Chairman Butters remarked, “It’s the only tool we’ve got left.”

Archival Note: This article has been dynamically reconstructed from the original public record print archives of the Patriot Ledger

More…

  • Supreme Court Nixes Norwood Power Suit Appeal-October 10, 2007

    The U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear an appeal regarding a $78 million ruling against the town in its dispute with former electricity provider New England Power Co. With the exception of the interest amount owed, this decision effectively concludes the nine-year legal battle between the town and New England Power. In February, the U.S.…

  • War Crimes Trial of Former Norwood Resident Suspended-July 4, 2000

    The war crimes trial of former Norwood resident Aleksandras Lileikis reached an indefinite suspension in July 2000, marking a controversial end to the proceedings.

    Scales of justice balanced with a gavel and a book, surrounded by legal papers and books
  • Two Norwood Restaurants Lock Legal Horns Over Town’s Final Available Liquor License-August 8, 1990

    With competing applications from O’Toole’s on Carnegie Row and The Great American Pub off Route 1, Norwood selectmen voted 3-1 to proceed with hearings despite legal threats from rival attorneys over zoning technicalities.

  • Norwood to Sue Blue Hills School to Block Budget-July 19, 1990

    The town of Norwood was on a collision course with the Blue Hills Regional Technical School in July 1990, as officials prepared to file a lawsuit to block the school’s revised budget for the upcoming academic year. The dispute had been brewing for several weeks, ever since the four district towns – Norwood, Holbrook, Dedham,…

  • Norwood Joins Lawsuit Against Governor Dukakis Over Withheld State Aid-August 29, 1989

    Norwood joins Brookline and other suburbs suing Governor Michael S. Dukakis over withheld state aid, even as unexpected local revenues nearly cover the town’s $1.1 million shortfall.

  • Fortuneteller Miller Plans Lawsuit Against Norwood Following License Denial-July 13, 1989

    Selectman Gary Lee led the opposition, citing concerns about the occult, while Miller argued the denial violated her civil rights.

    Tarot cards The Fool, The High Priestess, and Death laid out on a wooden surface with a hand holding the Death card
  • Selectmen Seek Injunction to Block 32 Percent Cable TV Rate Hike-August 21, 1985

    Norwood selectmen vote unanimously to take Adams-Russell Cablevision to court over a planned 32 percent rate hike affecting 5,800 residents.

  • Norwood Hospital Denies Treating Former New England Patriot Greg Taylor in $30 Million Lawsuit-October 6, 1982

    Norwood Hospital denies any record of treating former New England Patriots player Greg Taylor, blasting his $30 million lawsuit as irresponsible and false.

  • SNARC Files Court Action Over Willett School Lease Dispute-October 29, 1982

    Facing zoning roadblocks from town officials, SNCARC Director William F. Abel announced the agency filed a Superior Court lawsuit to secure a lease for the closed Willett School.

  • Dog Officer and Resident Trade Accusations Following Stun Gun Incident-August 29, 1981

    Selectmen reveal that dog officer Frank Rodak claims he was struck in the face before using a stun gun on a resident during a loose dog call on Hampden Drive.


Discover more from Norwood Historical Society

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.