Judge Hallisey Schedules Friday Hearing on Injunction Bid After Dempsey, Rich, and Lydon Sign Cinema at Norwood Permit “Under Protest”

NORWOOD – A Norfolk Superior Court judge declined on Wednesday morning, November 21, 1973, to issue an immediate restraining order blocking the Cinema at Norwood from screening the X-rated Marlon Brando drama “Last Tango in Paris” that evening, instead scheduling a formal court hearing for Friday, November 23, to determine whether an injunction should be granted. Reported in The Patriot Ledger on Wednesday, November 21, 1973 (combining breaking morning court coverage with full reporting of the Tuesday night Norwood Board of Selectmen session), Judge Hallisey’s ruling followed a tense municipal standoff in which selectmen reluctantly signed a Sunday exhibition license for the film’s scheduled November 25 showing while simultaneously directing Town Counsel Justin C. Barton to ask Dedham Superior Court to halt the screenings.

During Tuesday evening’s meeting, three selectmen—Walter J. Dempsey, Charles L. Rich, and John F. Lydon—signed the Sunday license “under protest” only after Town Counsel Barton warned that refusing the permit could expose the Town of Norwood to financial liability for damages. Board Chairman William F. Butters and Selectman Joseph W. Wall refused to sign the license altogether.

Barton offered selectmen sobering legal guidance, explaining that recent U.S. Supreme Court obscenity rulings had created “greater confusion than previously” regarding X-rated films. Under the new legal standard, Barton noted, prosecutors had to prove that a motion picture’s dominant theme appealed to the prurient interest of the average person, was patently offensive to statewide community standards, and lacked any socially redeeming value. He added that “Last Tango in Paris” had not yet been tested under Massachusetts obscenity statutes—noting that officials in Danvers had tried unsuccessfully to block it, and that an attorney involved in X-rated film disputes in Norwell had told him he “seriously doubted the movie would be considered obscene.”

Selectman Dempsey, who had previously withheld comment on the license application, told the meeting he had “taken a few hours off” earlier Tuesday to view the film firsthand, offering a terse three-word verdict: “Dirty, vulgar and degrading.” Nevertheless, to shield the town from potential lawsuits while pursuing judicial intervention, Barton advised signing the Sunday permit and immediately seeking a court injunction. As members affixed their signatures to pave the way for the Superior Court petition, Chairman Butters remarked, “It’s the only tool we’ve got left.”

Archival Note: This article has been dynamically reconstructed from the original public record print archives of the Patriot Ledger

More…

  • Paul J. Donovan Cleared of Wrongful Arrest-July 9, 1981

    Discover the story of Paul J. Donovan, a Norwood businessman wrongfully arrested after locating a stolen bicycle for a customer, and his subsequent exoneration in Dedham District Court.

  • Selectmen Seek Revaluation Funds to Avoid State Court Action-September 5, 1979

    Facing an October 31 deadline imposed by the state Department of Revenue, the Board of Selectmen agreed last night to place a request for $226,000 on the warrant for the upcoming special town meeting to fund mandatory property revaluation at 100 percent market value. Commissioner of Revenue L. Joyce Hampers warned selectmen in an August…

  • Norwood Teachers Association & Taxpayers File Lawsuit Over School Budget Cuts-July 22, 1978

    Back in July 1978, community tensions over municipal spending reached a boiling point when the Norwood Teachers Association and 36 local taxpayers filed a lawsuit in Norfolk Superior Court to overturn a $618,795 cut to the school budget.

  • Taxpayers Sue to Restore School Budget-July 6, 1978

    Seeking to prevent a mid-summer school closure, 36 Norwood taxpayers filed a lawsuit in 1978 to restore $600,000 in education funding.

    Stacked textbooks for school subjects topped with bundles of cash in a classroom
  • Ambrose J. Kelly Threatens Legal Action Over Winter Street Traffic and Abandonment Status-July 28, 1977

    Ambrose J. Kelly threatened to contact the district attorney regarding Winter Street unless selectmen closed the road or repealed its town-voted abandonment.

  • Poll Shows Strong Local Opposition to Repealing Sunday “Blue Laws”-October 13, 1976

    A Norwood Chamber of Commerce survey indicates local business members strongly favor retaining Sunday “blue laws” while overwhelmingly rejecting uniform electric rates.

  • Norwood School Committee to Reconsider Four Student Injury Insurance Claims-August 11, 1975

    Prompted by committeeman Joseph M. Pentowski, the Norwood School Committee agreed to review four student injury insurance claims totaling at least $3,000, including dental and surgical expenses stemming from school athletic and playground accidents.

  • Superior Court Denies Immediate Ban on “Last Tango in Paris” After Selectmen Reluctantly Sign Sunday License-November 21, 1973

    Norfolk Superior Court Judge Hallisey denied an immediate ban on “Last Tango in Paris” at the Cinema at Norwood in November 1973 and set a Friday hearing after Norwood selectmen signed a Sunday license “under protest” to avoid town liability

  • Developer Awarded $24,000 in Damages in Lawsuit Against ’67 Norwood Selectmen-August 31, 1972

    A Norfolk Superior Court judge has awarded developer George H. Clark of Southboro $24,000 in damages plus interest in a civil lawsuit brought against members of the 1967 Norwood Board of Selectmen. The ruling follows a four-day, jury-waived trial regarding the wrongful denial of a municipal sewer connection permit. Background of the Lawsuit and Court…

  • Norwood Selectmen Scrutinize Ponderosa Lounge Liquor License and Police Reporting Procedures-August 2, 1972

    The Norwood Board of Selectmen debated an alleged liquor license violation at the Ponderosa Lounge, with owner Daniel O’Leary denying unauthorized live musical entertainment.


Discover more from Norwood Historical Society

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.