A simmering dispute over the proposed expansion of commuter rail parking reached a new stage on July 09, 1987, as the Norwood Parking Committee formally challenged the statistical findings of an MBTA study.

Comic illustration showing Boston MBTA green and orange trains at Government Center and North Station with crowds

The conflict centers on a proposed parking deck at the Norwood Depot—a project that has met with significant resistance from local residents, hundreds of whom have attended public hearings and signed petitions to oppose the construction. The MBTA has used its April parking study to argue that a significant portion of vehicles parked at the Norwood stations are owned by non-residents from across the region, thereby justifying the need for a large-scale parking structure. However, the Norwood Parking Committee claims these findings are skewed by the inclusion of data from distant towns, misrepresenting the actual daily usage patterns of local commuters.

Edward McKenna, chairman of the parking study, spearheaded an effort to re-examine the data by excluding vehicles from communities considered too far away to provide daily rail commuters. By filtering out these 76 vehicles, the committee concluded that 57 percent of the cars in the lots are owned by Norwood residents, a figure substantially higher than the 49 percent reported by the MBTA. According to the MBTA’s original breakdown, residents from Walpole, Westwood, and Medfield made up a combined majority of the parking lot occupancy. Conversely, the committee’s recalculated figures suggest a far more localized reliance on the lots: 57 percent from Norwood, 16 percent from Walpole, 15 percent from Westwood, and 3 percent from Medfield, with all other municipalities accounting for less than 1.5 percent each.

The discrepancy in these figures is central to the debate over whether the town requires the significant infrastructure investment of a multi-level parking deck. The current proposals on the table include a more modest option of repaving and relining the existing lot at the Norwood Depot, which would add roughly 64 spaces to the current capacity of 143. More ambitious proposals involve the construction of a one- or two-deck parking facility. Residents have been vocal in their opposition to the deck, viewing it as an unnecessary transformation of the station area that does not accurately reflect the parking needs of the local population. As the parking committee continues to advocate for its own interpretation of the usage data, the town remains divided on how best to accommodate the demand for commuter parking while preserving the character of the surrounding neighborhoods.

Archival Note: This article has been dynamically reconstructed from the original public record print archives of the Patriot Ledger

More…

  • Norwood in 1876: What the Old Map Reveals

    1876 Map of Norwood

  • Norwood Commuters Don’t Cut Train-This Day In Norwood History-June 24, 1981

    Transit officials lay out a proposal reducing the Norwood line to six daily runs each way while pushing one-way ticket prices up to $1.75.

  • Norwood Commuting Hearing Requested-This Day In Norwood History-June 26, 1968

    Planners present data showing a two-dollar weekly savings per rider, while state lawmakers scramble to pass emergency MBTA subsidy extensions.

    MBTA train numbered 1010 at Back Bay station platform at 7:14 PM inbound to Boston
  • New York Express Jumps Track at Norwood, But None Injured-This Day In Norwood History-June 26, 1920

    SCENE IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE TRAIN WRECK IN NORWOOD ON THE NEW HAVEN. More than 135 passengers escaped serious injury yesterday when the 11:21 train from Boston for Hartford and New York on the Midland Division, jumped the rails at Winslow station in Norwood. The steel cars prevented a big loss of life. The photo shows…

  • The New Railroad Station-This Day In Norwood History-July 26, 1897

    This Day In Norwood History-July 26, 1897-The New Railroad Station

  • Grade Crossing Matter to be Referred by Court to a Master-This Day In Norwood History-March 25, 1892

    COSTLY CHANGES IN NORWOOD. After a lengthy discussion between counsel for the New York & New England Railroad Company and counsel for the town of Norwood, the objections filed by the railroad company to the acceptance of the report of commissioners in relation to the abolition of four-grade crossings in Norwood, were referred by Justice…

  • Winslow Train Station Abolished, Leading to Construction of Subway Hill-This Day In Norwood History- July 17, 1891

    This Day In Norwood History- July 17, 1891-Winslow Train Station Abolished, Leading to Construction of Subway Hill


Discover more from Norwood Historical Society

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.