Selectmen Vote 4-0 to Order Appraisal and Send Sale Request to Spring Town Meeting After State Orders $135,000 Handicapped Elevator
NORWOOD – Norwood Town Meeting representatives were slated to decide the following spring whether to sell the historic former firehouse in downtown Norwood Center to the owners of Carla’s Restaurant, the acclaimed eatery occupying the landmark building. Reported by Patriot Ledger staff writer Stephen Walsh on Wednesday, November 18, 1987, the Norwood Board of Selectmen voted 4-0 on Tuesday night, November 17, to place the proposed sale on the spring Town Meeting warrant and to commission an independent real estate appraisal of the property ahead of the vote.
Carla’s leased the two-story brick structure on Nahatan Street directly across from Norwood Town Hall—a municipal landmark vacated by the Norwood Fire Department in 1964 when firefighters relocated to their quarters at 137 Nahatan Street (printed as “Nathan Street” in the original newspaper dispatch). Appearing before selectmen alongside attorney James Hilliard, restaurant co-owner Carla Foley requested that the town sell the building to her and business partner Peter Maglia after the Massachusetts Architectural Access Board ordered installation of a handicapped-accessible elevator estimated to cost $135,000.
“You can’t expect Carla’s to absorb that cost in the remaining six years of the lease, especially after the initial investment already made,” Hilliard argued. “And the town may not want to pay for the elevator since it is not using the building.” Hilliard noted that since signing a 10-year lease in 1983, Foley had invested $535,000 in building renovations, furniture, and restaurant equipment, while paying roughly $33,000 annually in municipal rent plus $365 per month to lease customer parking spaces. Emphasizing the restaurant’s spotless civic record, Hilliard added that Carla’s had generated zero traffic, health, or liquor complaints over four years of operation and had contributed $8,500 to the Norwood Scholarship Fund the previous year.
Selectmen praised Foley’s transformation of the property into a premier downtown dining anchor—an establishment recognized by Boston Magazine as the best Italian restaurant on the South Shore, awarded four out of five stars by The Middlesex News, and ranked the second-best restaurant on the South Shore by the Greater Boston Restaurant Guide. Selectman John Kinnaly recalled that prior to Carla’s 1983 renovation, the vacant firehouse had deteriorated into “a rundown shell” and “really a dump” requiring constant municipal spending on paint and broken window glass: “We need a restaurant that will bring business into the downtown with all the empty stores.”
Selectman Joseph Curran echoed the praise while underscoring the town’s fiduciary obligation: “In the 17 years I’ve been sitting on the board, one of my proudest accomplishments has been to bring Carla to Norwood. I’m tremendously pleased with what you have done. But I’m not going to give the building to you; you’ll have to pay.” While Hilliard suggested it would be unfair for Foley to bid against outside buyers seeking to capitalize on improvements she had funded herself, Foley stated she was prepared to meet market value: “I’ve tried to make the people of Norwood proud. I saw things in that building that others didn’t see. I’ve invested my life in it. I understand others may bid on it; I’ll pay the price needed for it.” Town Counsel Justin Barton advised the board that selectmen could ask Town Meeting for authority to sell the building exclusively to Carla’s, though Town Meeting retained the power to amend the article and require open public bidding.
1987 Former Firehouse & Carla’s Figures Adjusted to 2026 Dollars & Site Legacy
Inflation-adjusted using U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI data ($1.00 in Nov. 1987 ≈ $2.83 in 2026)
| 1987 Restaurant Investment / Cost Item | 1987 Amount | 2026 Equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Carla’s Initial Renovation & Equipment Investment (1983) | $535,000 | ~$1,514,050 |
| State-Ordered Handicapped Elevator Estimate | $135,000 | ~$382,050 |
| Annual Municipal Lease Rent Paid to Town | ~$33,000 / yr | ~$93,390 / yr |
| Norwood Scholarship Fund Contribution | $8,500 | ~$24,055 |
| Monthly Customer Parking Space Lease | $365 / mo | ~$1,033 / mo |
Archival Note: This article has been dynamically reconstructed from the original public record print archives of the Patriot Ledger
More…
Discover more from Norwood Historical Society
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.









