Coach Gus Giardi’s Mustangs—Averaging 31 Points Over Last Three Games Behind Quarterback Jeff Putman—Aim to Snap Dedham’s Four-of-Five Streak and Protect 33-31-3 Series Edge
NORWOOD – A classic clash of styles awaited holiday football fans on Thanksgiving morning, Thursday, November 23, 1989, as Norwood High School’s surging, high-powered offense prepared to square off against Dedham High School’s dominant, five-shutout defense in the annual Bay State League Thanksgiving rivalry game. Reported in The Patriot Ledger on Wednesday, November 22, 1989, the preview spotlighted a rivalry that had been contested on Thanksgiving since 1921, with Norwood clinging to a narrow 33–31–3 all-time series lead—even though Dedham had captured four of the previous five meetings, including a 37–7 victory in 1988.
Entering the finale at 5–4 overall (4–4 in Bay State League play), head coach Gus Giardi’s Mustangs had won two straight games before letting a 12–2 halftime lead slip away against Framingham South, while averaging an explosive 31 points per game over their final three outings. Junior or senior quarterback Jeff Putman had thrown for 1,231 yards and 12 touchdowns, spreading the ball among split end Mike Connolly (28 receptions, 327 yards, 4 touchdowns) and fullback/defensive back Paul Menyo (28 receptions, 385 yards, 4 touchdowns), though tight end Chris Grant was sidelined with a twisted knee. On the ground, tailback/cornerback Brian Gugliotta had piled up 576 rushing yards and five touchdowns in just five games, supported by fullback/linebacker Bill Jacobs and an offensive line anchored by tackles Paul Fitzpatrick and Jim Ford, guards Barrett Prinz and Steve Smith, center Shane Hayman, and tight end/defensive end Mike Riley.
Defensively, Norwood relied on Riley, Fitzpatrick, end Phil Gallant, tackle Bill O’Neill, linebackers Mike Noe, Tim Coyle, and Brian Needham, and safety Jeff Mahoney. “We’re 5-4, and our team hasn’t disappointed me anywhere along the way,” Giardi said. “We’ve played the good teams very well. I expect us to play a strong game on both sides. In the second half of the season, our offense has come to life. We’re going to have to be playing at 101 percent every second of the game. We can’t have lapses against a team of this quality.”
Across the field, head coach Bob Lynch’s Dedham Marauders marched into Thanksgiving at 7–2 overall (6–2 in the Bay State League) riding a four-game winning streak—highlighted by three consecutive shutouts followed by a 13–7 victory over Natick. Dedham had blanked five opponents during the 1989 campaign while outscoring the opposition 179–57. Offensively, quarterback John Warren directed a ball-control attack led by halfback/defensive back Derek Sawayer (13 touchdowns), running back/defensive back Bobby Doherty (7 touchdowns), fullback Dave Abbott, end Tom Farren, tackles Steve Strickland and Bill Counihan, guards Dino Rizzi and Bobby Carroll, and center Bob McDonough.
Dedham’s formidable defense featured two-way tackle/nose guard Bill Counihan—identified by the Ledger as the key Marauder lineman Norwood needed to neutralize—alongside ends Mark Melnitsky and Tom Radosta, tackles Joe Pucillo and Jamie O’Conner, linebacker Jason Mammone, safety Joe Antonuccio, and free safety John Warren. “I would expect Norwood will try to take advantage of their three receivers, Grant, Connolly and Menyo,” Lynch noted before kickoff. “Defensively, we will have to be very aggressive. We want to run and keep the ball as long as possible. Our seniors want to go out in style.”
1989 Norwood vs. Dedham Thanksgiving Matchup Breakdown
| Category | Norwood Mustangs | Dedham Marauders |
| 1989 Overall Record | 5–4 | 7–2 |
| Bay State League Record | 4–4 | 6–2 |
| Head Coach | Gus Giardi | Bob Lynch |
| Key Offensive Leaders | QB Jeff Putman (1,231 yds, 12 TD), TB Brian Gugliotta (576 yds, 5 TD), SE Mike Connolly (28 rec, 327 yds, 4 TD), FB Paul Menyo (28 rec, 385 yds, 4 TD) | HB Derek Sawayer (13 TD), RB Bobby Doherty (7 TD), QB John Warren, FB Dave Abbott |
| Key Defensive Standouts | DE/TE Mike Riley, DT/OT Paul Fitzpatrick, DE Phil Gallant, DT Bill O’Neill, LBs Mike Noe, Tim Coyle, Brian Needham, S Jeff Mahoney | NG/OT Bill Counihan, DEs Mark Melnitsky & Tom Radosta, DTs Joe Pucillo & Jamie O’Conner, LB Jason Mammone, S Joe Antonuccio & FS John Warren |
| All-Time Series (Since 1921) | Leads 33–31–3 | Trails 31–33–3 (won 4 of last 5; won 37–7 in 1988) |
Archival Note: This article has been dynamically reconstructed from the original public record print archives of the Patriot Ledger
More Football Stories
-
‘Butch’ Songin Recalled To Canadian Grid Wars-August 23, 1956

This Day In Norwood History-August 23, 1956-‘Butch’ Songin Recalled To Canadian Grid Wars
-
Exodus Of Veterans Leaves Football Coach Scafati With Problem-September 15, 1955

Green Grid Squad Drills At Hilltop Norwood High’s 1955 football edition went through their paces yesterday in preparation for their first game against Needham on Saturday, September 24th. However, lacking this year are the familiar names of Eppich, Costello, Renzi, Dunn and company. It is here that Coach “Andy” Scafati and his staff face their…
-
Junior Varsity Football Revived At High School-This Day in Norwood History-October 23, 1946

Junior Varsity Football Revived At High School-This Day in Norwood History-October 23, 1946
-
Future Football Stars-This Day in Norwood History-October 11, 1946

Future Football Stars-This Day in Norwood History-October 11, 1946
-
Dedham, Norwood in Scoreless Tie-This Day in Norwood History-November 26, 1942

Timer’s Gun Halts Former Six Inches from Goal line Underdog Dedham High rose to the heights today and outplayed the undefeated Norwood High team in a game that ended in a scoreless tie before 6000 fans. The Heaphymen were denied a win only by the timer’s gun. After two powerful lines clashed for 47 minutes,…
-
Foul Blow at Football Game Nearly Caused a Riot at Prospect Park-This Day In Norwood History-November 18, 1904

Crowd Went Wild Between 1500 and 2000 people, men, women and children, embracing all classes and including clergymen, gathered at the football game at Prospect Park last Saturday afternoon. It was probably the largest outdoor crowd that has been gotten together at a Norwood function since the Old Home Week celebration of about two years…
Discover more from Norwood Historical Society
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
