Board Recalls High School Health Text Containing Abortion Sections, Orders Dec. 2 Probe, and Reviews 1971 Budget Estimates

NORWOOD – Norwood School Committee member Mrs. Rudith Berkowitz sparked a heated confrontation on Wednesday night, November 18, 1970, accusing local teachers and school administrators of “blatant disregard” for the School Committee’s statutory authority under Massachusetts General Laws. Reported in The Patriot Ledger on Thursday, November 19, 1970, Berkowitz cited three specific actions carried out without prior board approval: distributing a teacher-written health education manual to high school students, creating a kindergarten teacher aide position, and hiring a guidance counselor for the adult evening school program.

Reading from state statutes vesting sole legal authority over textbook purchases, personnel appointments, and position creation in the elected board, Berkowitz declared: “No one has the authority to discharge these duties but the school committee. Not the teachers, administrators or the superintendent.” She reserved her sharpest outrage for the high school health education manual—brought to her attention by parents questioning what was being taught in class—after reading excerpts addressing abortion methods. Calling its unapproved circulation “gross negligence on the part of administrators and a complete disregard for authority by teachers and department heads,” Berkowitz added: “In my naive optimism, I assumed any plans for curriculum revision would be submitted to the school committee.” She noted that a previous proposal for a communitywide advisory study of a family life education course—which had failed on a tie vote the prior spring—was “nothing compared to this.” Following an executive session requested by Berkowitz to discuss disciplinary action, Chairman Henry W. Diggs announced that administrators had been ordered to investigate who edited and circulated the manual and report back by December 2, confirming that all copies had been recalled on Tuesday.

Berkowitz also challenged the appointment of Norwood’s first teacher aide—assigned to kindergarten classes temporarily relocated from the overcrowded Winslow School to Emmanuel Lutheran Church—noting she had been questioned by residents because the district previously had no aides on any budget accounts. Superintendent Dr. Philip O. Coakley countered sharply: “You told me to get them out of there and that was what was needed.” A third clash erupted over hiring an adult evening school guidance counselor one night per week. While agreeing the service was worthwhile, Berkowitz insisted the committee should have been consulted first. Coakley and Assistant Superintendent James R. Donovan defended the hire as a routine administrative step funded within existing appropriations to expand adult guidance awareness. Committee member Charles C. Saraca angrily warned Coakley not to hire again without prior board approval, prompting an equally irate reply from Coakley that a previous board had authorized him to bring in appointments for confirmation—before Berkowitz clarified that the superintendent held authority to hire without prior approval only in genuine “emergency situations.”

In additional school board business during the session:

  • 1971 Preliminary Budget Estimates: Business Manager Joseph McDonald presented early 1971 expenditure projections—including $232,000 for transportation, $138,700 for utilities, $80,000 for new equipment, $69,207 for auxiliary agencies (libraries and nurses), $57,500 for contingency fees and services, $48,744 for custodial supplies, $10,000 for the school lunch program, and $8,500 for out-of-state travel—while Saraca urged tightening spending wherever possible.
  • Shattuck School Space & Custodial Grievance: The board discussed leasing or purchasing a temporary mobile classroom unit for Shattuck School (requesting cost estimates from Coakley by December 2) and referred a Norwood Public School Custodians Association grievance—over being required to report before 7:00 a.m. during school vacations and holidays—to the superintendent.

1970 Norwood School Department Budget Estimates Adjusted to 2026 Dollars

Inflation-adjusted using U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI data ($1.00 in Nov. 1970 ≈ $8.27 in 2026)

1971 Preliminary School Budget Category 1970 Estimate 2026 Equivalent
Student Transportation $232,000 ~$1,918,640
School Building Utilities $138,700 ~$1,147,049
New Equipment $80,000 ~$661,600
Auxiliary Agencies (Libraries & Nurses) $69,207 ~$572,342
Contingency Fees & Services $57,500 ~$475,525
Custodial Supplies & Administrative Expenses $48,744 ~$403,113
School Lunch Program $10,000 ~$82,700
Out-of-State Travel $8,500 ~$70,295

Archival Note: This article has been dynamically reconstructed from the original public record print archives of the Patriot Ledger

More…

  • Closing of the Everett School Causes Overcrowding Emergency-November 3, 1923

    Closing of the Everett School Causes Overcrowding Emergency-This Day In Norwood History-November 3, 1923

    Everett School
  • First Election Under New Town Manager Government-This Day In Norwood History-January 18, 1915

    NORWOOD CASTS ITS BIGGEST VOTE All ‘’Charter Committee” Candidates Elected. Appropriations Put Over to Adjourned Town Meeting Feb 25. NORWOOD, Jan 18 — The first town election under the new Town Government act took place today. There was a contest for the Board of Selectmen, and the largest vote of any annual town meeting was…

  • Norwood Schools To Open Sept 6 With Large Increase in Pupils and Many Changes-This Day in Norwood History- August 21, 1911

    Many Changes Made in Norwood Teaching Force Supt of Schools Austin H. Frittz has announced that the schools of Norwood will open for the fall term Wednesday, Sept 6. It is expected that the attendance on the opening day will be the largest in the history of the town. To accommodate the anticipated increase in…

  • Frank B. Boyden Not Compelled to Send Son to Public School-This Day In Norwood History-January 17, 1910

    DECIDES FOR FATHER. Action Brought by Norwood Committee Against Frank B. Boyden. Can the Norwood School committee compel Frank E. Boyden, the 12-year-old son of Frank B. Boyden of Pleasant st, to attend school, and if it can, should it oblige Mr. and Mrs. Boyden to send the boy to the public schools, was left…

  • Letter To The Editor About School Board Nominee Cornelius Callahan-This Day In Norwood History-February 25, 1904

    To the Editor of the Norwood Advertiser. Mr. Editor: I desire to call the attention of the voters of Norwood, to a few facts concerning C. M. Callahan, Esq., nominee for the school board. Mr. Callahan is a native of the town, a product of our public schools, and an energetic, and ambitious young man.…

  • Father Sues Town for $15,000 Because Proper Conveyance is Not Provided to School-November 22, 1895

    WANTS HIS CHILDREN CARRIED. This town is all in a ferment again over the so-called Gillin case. Away back in 1889 Rev George Hill, who was then chairman of the school board of Norwood, authorized Mr. James J. Gillon, who resides near the Dedham borderline and three miles from the nearest normal school house, to…

  • John Gillin Wants Children Carried to School-This Day In Norwood History-January 8, 1895

    Their Father Now Wants Damages Because Their Conveyance is Not Suitable. NORWOOD, Jan 8— Three suits, aggregating $15,000, have been brought by Mr. John Gillin, who resides in the Ellis district, against the town. Each suit is for $5000 and is brought as guardian for his three minor children for alleged damages, caused by the…

  • Should Norwood Hire a School Superintendent?-This Day in Norwood History-June 7, 1890

    June 8, 1890- The question of hiring a superintendent was raised at a lively town meeting. The following March, town meeting, empowered Mr. Maurice J. O’Brien , principal of the Everett School, to act in the capacity of Norwood’s first superintendent of schools.

  • Celebration of the Incorporation of the Town of Norwood-This Day In Norwood History-March 6, 1872

    NORWOOD THE VICINITY OF BOSTON. The New Town or Norwood. The inhabitants of this new town, which formerly has been known as South Dedham, last evening celebrated the formal incorporation of the town; Messrs. George Winslow, Isaac Colburn, J. Edward Everett, Elijah Wheeloek, George H. Morrill, George B. Talbot, J. Metcalf Baker, J. Warren Talbot,…

    Norwood Incorporation Celebration

Discover more from Norwood Historical Society

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.