Representatives Vote to Retain Town Manager John J. Carroll as Police Administrator After Hour-Long Debate Over Selectman John F. Kinnaly’s Proposals
NORWOOD – A decisive majority at Norwood’s adjourned Special Town Meeting voted on Thursday night, November 20, 1980, to reject a proposed Town Charter overhaul designed to expand the statutory authority of the Norwood Police Chief—preserving Town Manager John J. Carroll’s role as municipal police administrator and affirming his authority to appoint the town’s next chief of police. Reported by Patriot Ledger correspondent Marion Farley on Friday, November 21, 1980, the overwhelming vote followed an hour of pointed debate over two charter-amending articles sponsored by Selectman John F. Kinnaly amid the impending retirement of Police Chief James Curran and recent public scrutiny of the department.
Kinnaly—a former FBI agent—had originally intended to ask Town Meeting to adopt Chapter 97A of Massachusetts General Laws, commonly known as the “strong police chief” statute, before learning that state general laws could only be accepted at an Annual Town Meeting. In response, he drafted two Town Charter amendments incorporating Chapter 97A’s core provisions, which would have transferred hiring and firing power over the police chief from the Town Manager to the Board of Selectmen while granting the chief sweeping operational autonomy comparable to that held by Norwood’s fire chief.
Arguing on the floor that leaving the Town Manager as police administrator bred confusion, eroded departmental effectiveness, damaged officer morale, and undermined public confidence, Kinnaly delivered a blunt assessment while Chief Curran sat silently at the rear of the Junior High School South auditorium: “We have a cancerous situation in the police department and adoption of these articles is the cure.”
Opponents pushed back strongly against altering Norwood’s Town Charter. Board of Assessors Chairman James Drummey drew the evening’s only applause when he urged Town Meeting members not to rewrite foundational municipal law over personnel disputes: “When we look deep enough into these problems, they are human weaknesses. Are we going to change the charter every time we have a human weakness?” Meanwhile, the Norwood Police Union hired a private stenographer to transcribe the debate—with union president Gerald Mahoney stating, “We want an accurate record of what is said,” and adding after the vote, “I think it is necessary to have a professional administrator as a buffer between the police and the politics.”
Several Town Meeting representatives remarked while leaving the hall that suspicion of political motives helped sink the measure, noting rumors that Kinnaly had fellow Norwood resident and former FBI agent Richard Krant “in the wings” as a candidate for police chief. Conceding defeat afterward, Kinnaly said he doubted he would revive the proposal at the spring Annual Town Meeting: “Town meeting has spoken.” Town Manager Carroll, who had assured members during the debate that “everything I’ve had to do with the department has been done in a highly professional manner,” declined extended comment after the vote, noting simply that he felt he had received a clear vote of confidence.
Archival Note: This article has been dynamically reconstructed from the original public record print archives of the Patriot Ledger
More Norwood Police Stories
-
Murphys of Norwood Have Done Their Share In the Interest of Law and Order-October 5, 1912
Murphys of Norwood Have Done Their Share In the Interest of Law and Order-This Day in Norwood History-October 5, 1912

Discover more from Norwood Historical Society
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
