Town Manager John P. Mogan and Hospital Administrator David P. Buchmueller Keep Architectural Valuations Confidential Before Tuesday Negotiations
NORWOOD – Two eagerly awaited architectural appraisals of the Norwood Civic Center property—one commissioned by Norwood Hospital and the other by the Town of Norwood—were formally submitted to Town Manager John P. Mogan on Friday, November 19, 1976, but were immediately withheld from public release. Reported in The Patriot Ledger on Saturday, November 20, 1976, the competing valuations were prepared to establish the dollar cost of replacing Norwood’s municipal recreation complex, a financial commitment the hospital had agreed to underwrite if Town Meeting approved selling the Civic Center parcel for hospital expansion.
Arriving for a closed-door meeting with Mogan and the project architects, Hospital Administrator David P. Buchmueller declined to disclose the hospital’s valuation figures, explaining that the numbers remained preliminary and subject to adjustment. Buchmueller noted that Norwood Hospital had commissioned two distinct calculations—one estimating full replacement construction cost and another reflecting the real estate value of the Civic Center’s central downtown location. “These architects have not had time to sit down and compare the figures. We may be far apart because of a small misunderstanding and if so, we’d like to clear that up before we make the figures public,” Buchmueller said.
Selectmen Chairman Joseph F. Curran had stated on Thursday that he preferred withholding the figures until selectmen and hospital leaders could negotiate a compromise during an executive session scheduled for Tuesday night, November 23, warning that premature disclosure could weaken the town’s bargaining position—though he initially indicated he would release them if Buchmueller consented. When reached by Mogan on Friday, however, Curran stated he would not unilaterally authorize releasing the valuations without consulting the full Board of Selectmen.
The hospital’s appraisal had been prepared by The Architects Collaborative of Cambridge, while Norwood retained the local firm of Korslund, LeNormand & Quann—with both architectural teams briefed jointly in advance by Mogan and Buchmueller to ensure identical evaluation guidelines. While Curran indicated both appraisals would be released Tuesday night once a compromise figure was reached, Buchmueller cautioned he was uncertain whether the raw architectural submissions would be made public, adding: “We are hoping to come in on Tuesday with a figure both sides can readily agree upon.” At a public forum the previous week, Buchmueller had stated that if the two appraisals landed within $50,000 of one another, the town and hospital should reach an easy agreement on a sale price, whereas a wider gap would require formal negotiation—though on Friday both Mogan and Buchmueller refused to reveal either the dollar figures or how far apart the estimates stood.
1976 Civic Center Appraisal Spread Threshold Adjusted to 2026 Dollars & Site Legacy
Inflation-adjusted using U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI data ($1.00 in Nov. 1976 ≈ $5.61 in 2026)
| 1976 Norwood Civic Center Negotiation Benchmark | 1976 Benchmark | 2026 Equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Maximum Appraisal Variance for Automatic Price Agreement | ≤$50,000 | ~$280,500 |
Archival Note: This article has been dynamically reconstructed from the original public record print archives of the Patriot Ledger
More Norwood Hospital Stories
-
Hostage Taken in Robbery, Officer Shot, 2 Arrested-This Day in Norwood History- September 7, 1974
This Day in Norwood History- September 7, 1974-Hostage Taken in Robbery, Officer Shot, 2 Arrested

-
Proposed Land Swap Between Norwood Civic Center and Hospital Expansion Site Generates Mixed Reactions-August 17, 1974
Candidate Francis J. Keady proposed trading the Norwood Civic Center for the hospital’s 24-acre Walpole expansion site, drawing skepticism from town manager John P. Mogan and selectman Joseph W. Wall.

-
Norwood Appeals Board Denies Permit For South Norwood Development-July 27, 1974
The Norwood Appeals Board rejected a nine-acre duplex development by Hobbs Realty Trust due to severe flooding risks, drainage issues, and emergency vehicle access concerns.

-
Norwood Police Chief James M. Murphy Dies At 54-November 23, 1973
Norwood Police Chief James M. Murphy, 54, died yesterday at Norwood Hospital, where he was admitted Thanksgiving Day after a heart attack. Chief Murphy, a Norwood police officer for 33 years and police chief for 10 years, was one of the state’s youngest police chiefs when appointed in 1963. A funeral Mass will be said…

-
Norwood Hospital to Combat Suburban Drinking Crisis-October 24, 1973
As Norwood Hospital’s new alcoholism coordinator, Joan Gallagher partners with local police and employers to address the hidden crisis of suburban alcoholism across the 11-town region.

-
Norwood Board Weighs Alternatives For Two Lyman Place Houses-October 17, 1973
Rewritten Narrative Feature A Town Divided Over Municipal Property The future of two Lyman Place houses—purchased by Town Meeting for $25,000—remains completely unresolved following a tense and ultimately inconclusive joint meeting between the Board of Selectmen, the Youth Commission, and representatives from the Pulse hotline. Situated near the public works yard, the properties were initially…

-
Budget-Minded Norwood Officials Form Committee to Trim Overweight Town Report-August 2, 1973
Following a record 580-page centennial town report costing $6,800, Norwood town manager John P. Mogan and local officials formed a special committee to cut extraneous material and reduce future printing costs.

-
Police-Fire Substation Proposed for Old South Norwood Theater Site-November 6, 1972
Led by Selectman William F. Butters, Norwood officials are moving to demolish the former South Norwood theater on Washington Street to construct a new public safety substation.

-
First Male Graduate Breaks Tradition at Peabody Practical Nursing School-August 28, 1972
David Thurber of Austin Street breaks tradition as the lone male among 32 graduates to become the Henry O. Peabody School’s first male licensed practical nurse.

Discover more from Norwood Historical Society
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

