Butters Family Sells Pharmacy-July 20, 1990

A significant chapter in the history of South Norwood business and family legacy came to an end on July 20, 1990. The Butters family pharmacy, a staple in the community for over four decades, ceased operations after Helen Butters, the selectman’s mother and president of the family business, decided to sell the pharmaceutical stock and customer list to Betro Pharmacy of Walpole.

The news of the pharmacy’s closure was met with sadness by William Butters, who had managed the store for decades. “Next to the death of one of our own,” he said, “I feel this worse.” The closure marked a significant milestone in his lifetime of public service, as he reflected on the end of an era.

The Butters family pharmacy was more than just a business; it was a family legacy that began in 1946 when William’s father, Harry, became a partner in an existing neighborhood pharmacy on Washington Street. Over time, the store evolved to include a liquor license and the sale of alcohol. In 1957, the family moved their business to the Paperama shopping plaza on Route 1.

The pharmacy was renowned for its exceptional service, employing a full-time pharmacist and two part-time pharmacists who catered to the needs of generations of customers. The store’s commitment to providing late-night services, with a pharmacist on duty until midnight, set it apart from other establishments in the area.

However, the Butters family pharmacy faced significant challenges in recent months. In May 1990, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) seized the store twice for unpaid federal taxes. William Butters had initially stated that the IRS overestimated the amount of taxes owed, but later clarified that the tax issues were unrelated to the decision to sell.

The true reason behind the closure lay in the difficulties faced by small businesses like the Butters family pharmacy. Delays in insurance reimbursements for medicines and competition from health maintenance organizations (HMOs) that filled their own prescriptions had taken a toll on the business’s cash flow. Suppliers demanded prompt payment, but the pharmacy struggled to keep up with the financial demands.

As William Butters succinctly put it, “This is a matter of cash flow.” The pressures of modern healthcare and the complexities of insurance reimbursement systems had become too much for small businesses like his family’s pharmacy to handle.

The closure of the Butters family pharmacy marked the end of an era in South Norwood. However, the liquor store remained operational, providing some solace to the community that had grown accustomed to the family’s presence on Washington Street and later at the Paperama shopping plaza.

As the town of South Norwood continued to evolve, the legacy of the Butters family pharmacy served as a reminder of the importance of small businesses in shaping local history. The story of William Butters and his family’s dedication to serving their community would remain an integral part of the town’s narrative for years to come.

Archival Note: This article has been dynamically reconstructed from the original public record print archives of the Patriot Ledger