Police Brandish Nightsticks and Call in Fire Pumper as Uninvited Crowds Swarm Nahatan Street and Storm Armory Doors
NORWOOD — More than 1,000 uninvited teenagers descended upon Norwood on a Tuesday night, creating a near-riot atmosphere that required a swift and heavy-handed response from local police. The chaotic scene unfolded at a Catholic Youth Organization (C.Y.O.) deanery dance held at the town armory, which was already packed to its maximum 900-person capacity.
When organizers turned away the massive overflow crowd, more than 1,000 youths milled outside along Nahatan Street for over an hour. Police Chief James M. Murphy, Fire Chief Irving J. Dobson, and Sergeant James Curran faced a surging mob that attempted to force entry by battering down a rear overhead door, climbing through side windows, and spilling across the roadway to catch a glimpse of the two performing rock-and-roll bands.
Band Advertising, ‘Beatle-Type’ Hairdos, and Police Intervention
While C.Y.O. officials had strictly limited attendance to official C.Y.O. members from surrounding parishes—including Canton, Stoughton, Sharon, Medfield, Needham, Westwood, and Foxboro—the massive turnout was accidentally fueled by relentless promotion. Police determined that one of the hired rock bands had aggressively advertised the Norwood dance at previous gigs across the region. A second unauthorized band from Dedham also showed up uninvited.
Both musical groups sported long, stringy “Beatle-type” hairdos that drove early teenage girls into a frenzy. Hundreds swarmed the musicians for autographs throughout the evening, with one 13-year-old girl famously asking a band member to autograph her bare wrist when she could not find writing paper.
As the crowd outside swelled past 1,200 and traffic on Nahatan Street came to a complete standstill, tensions boiled over:
- Capacity Overload: Fire Chief Dobson ordered 300 excess attendees removed from the hall, triggering immediate friction at the doors.
- Fire Pumper Deployed: With the mob threatening to riot, Chiefs Murphy and Dobson ordered a municipal fire pumper to the scene to clear the streets with its presence.
- Nightstick Clearances: Chief Murphy, wielding a long nightstick, personally led police details—assisted by Sergeants John Flaherty and William Travers—to disperse crowds trying to break through windows and rear doors.
- Clergy Assistance: More than a score of Catholic priests accompanying the youth groups patrolled the hall inside, actively assisting police in ejecting known troublemakers.
Despite the running street clashes, police reported no arrests and no serious injuries, eventually restoring order as roving patrols dispersed the remaining teenagers into the surrounding neighborhoods.
Archival Note: This article has been dynamically reconstructed from the original public record print archives of the Patriot Ledger
More Norwood Crime Stories
-
Makarewicz Refused Lie Detector Test, Jury Told-March 10, 1955
Peter Makarewicz refused to submit to a lie detector test when he was questioned about the murder of 15-year-old Geraldine Annese, it was testified today at the trial of the boy. The testimony was offered by State Police Sgt Walter Bogdanchik, who recounted the three interrogations of Makarewicz early the day after the Annese girl’s…

-
Prosecutor Claims Peter Plotted Murder-March 9, 1955
Peter Makarewicz, 15, of Norwood, deliberately plotted the murder of Geraldine Annese, the prosecution charged in its opening to a Superior Court jury here this afternoon. “He (Peter) planned this while lying beside his baby sister while she went to sleep sometime between 9 and 9:30 that night.” (the night of the slaying), Dist Atty.…

-
Defense Bans Women Jurors in Murder Trial-March 7, 1955
Eleven male jurors were selected by 2:45 this afternoon to hear the case in Norfolk Superior Court of 15-year-old Peter Makarewicz of Norwood, charged with the Nov. 5 murder of vivacious Geraldine Annese, 15, also of Norwood. It is expected that the entire panel of 12 jurors and two alternates will be completed before today’s…

-
Few Details Emerge In Case Against Peter Makarewicz On Eve Of Trial For Murder of Geraldine Annese-March 6, 1955
DEDHAM. March 6- Tall, slim, delicately handsome Peter Makarewicz, 15, of Norwood, goes on trial in Norfolk Superior Court Monday for the murder of pretty, 15-year-old Geraldine Annese, whose nude body was found in a garage next to her Norwood noma last Nov. 5. Makarewicz, long-time friend and neighbor of the slain, dark-haired high school…

-
Peter Makarewicz Goes on Trial Next Monday in Murder of Geraldine Annese-March 3, 1955
May Require Two Days To Select Jury By E. V. McLEAN Peler Makarewicz, 15-year-old South Norwood youth who is charged with the strangle slaying of his neighbor and school chum, Geraldine Annese on the night of last November 4, will go on trial for his life in the Norfolk Superior Criminal Court at Dedham on…

-
Judge Orders Most Evidence Be Shown to Defense in Geraldine Annese Murder Case-February 24, 1955
Goldstein To See State Exhibits Of Entire Case In an unprecedented ruling, Superior Court Judge Frank J. Donahue has ordered Norfolk County to turn over to the defense practically all its evidence against Peter Makarewicz, 15 – year – old Norwood youth scheduled to go on trial the week of March 7th in the slaying…

-
‘Good Boy’ Killed Girl Next Door, Police Say-December 5, 1954
‘Good Boy’ Killed Girl Next Door, Police Say-This Day In Norwood History-December 5, 1955

-
Peter Makarewicz To Confer With Counsel-November 15, 1954
Plan Defense in Peter Makarewicz Murder Trial- This Day In Norwood History-November 9, 1954

-
Girl’s Parents Soothe Alleged Killer’s Folks-November 8, 1954
Two Families in Dramatic Meeting, Join in Meal; Arraignment Today MOTHERS OF VICTIM, ACCUSED—Two grief-stricken mothers embrace in Norwood, Mass., as they sob out promises to pray for each other’s children—one slain, the other charged as the slayer. Mrs. Peter S. Makarewicz Sr., left, mother of a 15-year-old youth accused of the murder, and Mrs.…

-
Peter Makarewicz Confesses to Murder of Geraldine Annese-November 7, 1954
Peter Makarewicz Confesses to Murder of Geraldine Annese-This Day in Norwood History-November 7, 1954

Discover more from Norwood Historical Society
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
